Every now and then a player will come along who inspires the
phrase – he’s a "gritty" player. For Angel
fans names like David Eckstein come to mind almost immediately or perhaps Darin
Erstad or even… Bobby Grich.
For a long time – you could attach such a label to a ball
player and nobody would really question it at all. With the emergence of sabermetrics and more
in depth statistical analysis – some people view grit as nothing more than fairy
dust. In other words it’s not real
because it’s not really measurable.
Admit it; when you read the title of this blog, you smiled and maybe
even chuckled a bit at the notion that something like “grit” was real.
Is “grit” real? Are there
players who have it and those who don’t and is it a factor in the success or
failure of a player? Before you attempt
to answer those questions – please spend six minutes watching the video
below. It’s just six minutes long, but
it could shed some new light on the subject.
Duckworth describes grit in a variety of ways. She says it’s about “passion and perseverance.” She goes on to say that “grit is living life
like it’s a marathon, not a sprint.”
Her data shows that grit is “usually unrelated or even
inversely related to measures of talent.”
Duckworth also admits that science knows very little about
how to build it. Her studies are clear that
talent alone does not necessarily translate into success. In fact, her data shows that grit is
unrelated or inversely related to measures of talent.
The most telling part of her talk is that those who have
grit don’t view failure as a permanent condition. I think good closers have grit because they’re
able to put past failures behind them and attack the next opportunity.
The idea that grit is a factor also feeds into one of my own
philosophies about Cuban born players.
Given what some of them have had to go through just to have an
opportunity to play in the major leagues is beyond amazing. When you really think about guys like Kendrys
Morales who made 8 attempts to defect it makes you stop and realize that
playing baseball isn’t pressure at all.
In fact, it’s easy compared to their other life experiences. Does Morales have grit? I’d think he’d have to, wouldn’t you?
In any case - I think there's some merit to the notion that having grit matters. How about you?
I think it's an interesting question.
ReplyDeleteBut, if you really dig down and get gritty (so to speak), I would say the thing sabermetricians are railing against is the idea that grit can make up for a lack of talent.
If two players are of identical talent (impossible, I know) and one works harder than the other, his "grit" will manifest itself in on-field performance. So, grit in and of itself is no way to measure a ballplayer, but if it's part of the package, it will help him achieve.
So, in the end, results are what matters. How a player gets there (within the rules of the game, of course) isn't important.
Those are my two cents. Hope they add something to the discussion.